Reports on Exceptional Learners Deserve Music, Too!

This month, we're excited to share that Guitars and Ukes in the Classroom's work adapting music for all learners has made the headlines! A cutting edge educational group known as EALA, which stands for Educating All Learners Alliance, visited our pilot middle school in San Diego where we are teaming up to design and implement inclusive music. GITC has become an integral part of Arts Education at the Creative Performing Arts and Media Arts (CPMA) middle school You can learn more about EALA by following the second link in this report. EALA is made possible by InnovateEDU, a nonprofit, based in Brooklyn, NY, that has expanded into a number of nationwide research projects and initiatives to support under-resourced schools and educators. InnovateEDU focuses on the development of scalable tools and practices that leverage innovation, technology, and new human capital systems to improve education for all students and close the opportunity gap.

Several leaders from EALA came to observe our collaborative music inclusion initiative in its first year, and within an hour, they had rolled up their sleeves and were participating with the special ed teachers and music educators. They've now written and presented this CASE STUDY about CPMA's innovative approach. We're including the report here, but you will also find it at the link listed in this report. We've excluded last names in keeping with GlobalGiving.org's guidelines, but you can read the original report by clicking the link in this report.

Meeting diverse learning needs Music for All: Fostering Inclusion in the Arts Through Adapted Professional Development

In this case study, we explore how one middle school brought together music teachers and special education professionals to ensure full access and inclusion of all students within the arts.

Creative, Performing and Media Arts (CPMA) Middle School is an arts-focused magnet school in the San Diego Unified School District. CPMA believes that the arts provide opportunities for students to feel they belong, to grow and to express themselves, and to practice compassion and learn from one another. CPMA is a unique school in that it serves students from across the San Diego Unified School District. Within that population, CPMA has a large number of special education students with diverse learning needs.

Christine, who is responsible for coordinating professional learning and curriculum development for CPMA through the Magnet Schools Assistance Program (MSAP) grant Amplifying the Arts in the San Diego Unified School District, was looking for a way to grow and adapt the school’s existing arts programs to include new arts partners in order to increase arts equity, access, and opportunity for all learners.

To support this goal, Christine recognized the need for music educators, music integration specialists, and special education professionals to come together and share their knowledge. Thus, adapted professional development (PD) was born.

Setting the stage for collaboration

Adapted PD is a collaborative and interdisciplinary approach to educator learning aimed at meeting the diverse learning needs of students, particularly those whose disabilities have traditionally presented barriers to inclusion in arts education in the past. It involves connecting educators from different disciplines, providing training on adaptive techniques and tools, and developing shared strategies to ensure full access to arts education for students with specialized learning needs.

CPMA is committed to cultivating a welcoming, safe, collaborative culture for all, and CPMA’s MSAP grant goals are focused on developing interdisciplinary, arts-integrated and inclusive learning experiences for all students. Thus, developing a professional learning experience that brings together educators from various backgrounds, disciplines, and expertise to grow together cross-departmentally, engaging educators in deep collaborative and active learning, and providing time together for co-planning, is critical to aligning the school’s mission while advancing arts education for all educators and their students.

The first challenge of implementing adapted PD at CPMA was simply coordinating schedules so that teachers could have time to collaborate. Teachers were given a sub and released from their classroom for a one-day workshop. Related service providers like paraprofessionals and occupational, speech, and physical therapists were also included in the training.

For the first time, music educators and special education professionals had an opportunity to be together in the same space and build connections.

Bridging music and special education

In the morning, teachers focused on developing a mutual understanding of one another’s disciplines and teaching practices, and on defining shared student learning objectives for the adapted music program. CPMA also brought in Guitars and Ukes in the Classroom (GITC), a nonprofit organization that trains and equips teachers to adapt and integrate music into the classroom experience. The full team worked together to delve into the underlying questions and possibilities of collaboratively creating an inclusive music program.

“Our ed specialists have such deep knowledge of each of their individual students’ strengths, needs, and the accommodations and modifications that work well for them. Our music teachers have such strong expertise in their craft. We gave them that time to connect and learn from one another,” says Christine.

Then in the afternoon, they participated in hands-on training with GITC to develop the capacity to adapt and lead music for inclusion of students with specific abilities and challenges.

According to GITC’s founder and executive director, Jessica, one of the biggest challenges is getting non-music educators comfortable with music.

“When a program like this is put in place, there will be teachers who are early adopters, and they will embrace it fully. Others may be more hesitant because making music is not yet in their comfort zone. The path to helping them develop musical skills and comfort level is providing free, ongoing training for those who wish to try.”

To overcome these obstacles, teachers and support staff were given time to play instruments, including percussion, ukuleles, and kazoos, while learning different adaptive strategies. GITC also provides ongoing free virtual and in-person training PD workshops and courses for interested educators and support staff.

After the workshop was over, GITC’s teaching artist Sharon went into a variety of classrooms serving Special Education students for 8-13 weeks to facilitate instruction in adapted music and music integration, and to provide ongoing support.

“It takes time to build trust with not only the students, but also with the instructors and aides as well,” Sharon explains.

Harmonizing inclusion

Thanks to adapted PD and the partnership with Guitars in the Classroom, CPMA has built a collaborative, inclusive environment for both students and staff. Educators have grown in their own practice and now have the confidence to lead even in Sharon’s absence.

A major win was seeing teachers and support staff utilizing strategies like visual schedules, kinesthetic and tactile cueing, and hand-over-hand support.

“When we went into classrooms [before the adapted PD], some of the parapros were standing back. They wanted to help, but the instruments were foreign objects,” recalls Jessica. “Now, they are taking it upon themselves to successfully engage the students in playing the instruments with a combination of strategies.”

Sharon and Jessica also guided CPMA on the best way to spend their grant funds to purchase adapted music equipment like Makala Waterman ukuleles made of an indestructible and easily sanitized colorful polymer, non-slip mats to keep instruments in place for wheelchair users, adaptive finger picks for students who struggle with grip, different types of mallets and drumsticks, and a variety of repertoire choices that cater to students’ strengths and needs.

This has not only improved access to music education, but also increased integration of music into the special education classrooms. Students now use music for self-soothing, classroom transitions, and even ask for instruments during choice time.

The end result? Authentic, dignified participation in music instruction for all.

“I was just in one of our adapted music classrooms the other day and saw 100% of students engaging in their own way,” says Christine. “They’re not all using the same instruments at the same time or in the same way, but they’re all making music while making progress toward learning goals, and they’re all contributing meaningfully to the classroom environment.”

Thanks, Friends for making this ground-breaking case study possible with your steadfast support! Every donation to this project results in improving the quality of life and learning for students with all kinds and every level of exceptionalities!

So grateful for your care and enthusiasm!

Jess